An Interview with Bente Scheller

My latest is also for SyriaUntold, an interview on the foreign policies of the states most interested in the Syrian case, with one of the premier (in my opinion), Syria analysts, Bente Scheller.

Whoever thinks reconstruction could be used as an incentive for the regime to become less brutal or to allow for the return of refugees; whoever believes it would be possible to set conditions and expect the regime to deliver lives in a fantasy world.

The interview was also translated into Arabic, which I think is a first for me.

English version

Arabic version

Turkey stops registering Syrian asylum seekers

According to this HRW dispatch .

It is a wonder quite how long Turkey has been able to erect a border wall with Syria, stop admitting refugees entry, shooting and killing some who try to cross the border, and not hosting them with full rights. How long can this go on with no condemnation from Europe or Canada or the US?

At the same time those countries vilify Turkey and Turks and conflate Erdogan with everything. And they never give Turkey much credit for hosting between 3 and 4 million refugees, they never seem to reflect on the every day solidarity that has taken for many ordinary Turks. Yet of course they paint their own refugees as burdens they are virtuously carrying. Because they don’t give credit where it is due nor criticism where it is due it is almost as if they know nothing about Turkey at all…

A Portrait of the Refugee as a Young Man

“They put me in the car tire, chest to knees. They break your fingers. And they started to hit me, asking me to count. They make a joke with you — if you say it is eleven, but it is nine, then they start again from the zero. They took me out of the tire after 150 strikes and the Colonel asked me again, ‘Did you want to escape from the army?’ I fainted a few times and they were still hitting me, so I woke up. They don’t care if you are conscious or unconscious.”

Hosam had been caught deserting a regime that committed war crimes — wanted him to commit war crimes — to attack unarmed countrymen and countrywomen. They tortured Hosam at great length. Then he nearly starved, escaping Hama on foot after they came for him again. These were dramatic events in his life. He was fortunate to get to Turkey.

What followed is far less captivating. The absence of those evocative words — torture, war crimes, starvation — belies Hosam’s reality. In Turkey, like so many Syrians, he is being ground down slowly.

“The newspapers engage poor desperate wretches, out-of-work clerks and commercial travellers and the like, who for a while make frantic efforts and keep their sales up to the minimum; then as the deadly work wears them down they are sacked and fresh men are taken on.”

That was Orwell describing newspaper subscription hawkers, but the last phrase could just as well describe the working conditions for most Syrians in Turkey. Today Hosam works in a factory. He lives with Walid and Walid’s older brother, Nasser, the latter who works in the same factory.

WhatsApp Image 2018-06-14 at 01.46.06

Hosam in Antalya

Nasser came to Turkey just six months ago. He was a taxi driver in Hama, with a wife and kids. But he got called, at age 38, to join Assad’s husk of an army. Refusal means detention or worse. When war criminals come calling, what would you do?

Yes, there are still refugees from Syria coming to Turkey in 2018, for the same reasons, for all the convenient narration that the Syrian crisis is winding down. Separated from his family, Walid tells me, he needs to send remittance. He worked for a Turkish businessman in the neighbourhood — Sultanbeyli on the asian side of Istanbul — for two months after he first arrived. After two months he was ghosted without ever being paid a dime. His brother, who now has strong Turkish, went to the police office with him. They said they would look into it and did nothing. Nasser already paid a high price to get smuggled to Turkey — the border is closed — and his first two months as a refugee were spent working hard, for nothing.

This has been happening in Turkey, where Syrians work without the protection of the law, the slow debilitating grind of economic oppression. Because Syrian work is not regularised or legalised, many get stiffed or shorted on their salary, across all industries. In Gaziantep employers can let Syrians go as soon as they burn out. There are fresh, eager, unemployed Syrians with equal qualifications waiting to take their place (as per the Orwell quote). The wages for which they are working are hard to process. 1,000 Tl a month for 70 hour weeks of unskilled manual labour is commonplace in Gaziantep, with no days off allowed. Child labourers work full time for as little as 50Tl a week.

A similar thing happened to Hosam over the summer. He had stayed in Antalya, where his story in Turkey began, working at a vacation resort (previous to that he worked at a stone-breaking factory). The resort told him there was no more work in the fall and he left for Istanbul in the early winter without having collected his pay for either July or August.

WhatsApp Image 2018-06-18 at 23.42.56

When Hosam gets injured on the job (picture left) he does not get danger pay, time off, or even stitches. The same for Walid’s factory job. When I visited in the waning days of Ramadan, Walid had a thigh contusion the size of a grapefruit that made it difficult to walk. Running after a switch that was on when it should have been off, he had not seen some jutting steel rebar. The contusion was such that, for days, he could barely bend the leg. Not only did he receive no sympathy for this workplace injury — when he had to miss nearly three weeks work earlier in the year, his back in traction, he almost lost his job entirely. His boss threatened him — if he didn’t provide a doctor’s note, Walid might be fired.

I stayed with Hosam, Walid, and Nasser two nights last week. In the day between I visited a friend, an architect, who is also missing months of pay from his job. He even became a Turkish citizen, by way of his qualifications, and has access to much more recourse than 99% of Syrians in Turkey. But his employers told him he did not need to come back to work after Eid and there is no sign of the money he is owed.

It is the same story over and over. One of the first interviews I did in Istanbul, 2.5 years ago, another, different Syrian friend had been stiffed for seventeen days worth of tiling work — skilled labour for which he studied and was certified in Syria. For Syrians as refugees in Turkey the margin for error is low. To work a grueling job for seventeen days and receive nothing is for many a devastating setback.

More often than being stiffed is Syrians getting shorted. The boss hands them a manilla, bill-sized envelope in the presence of the entire staff. If they take it out to count the money there are consequences — the boss will accuse them of not trusting him and threaten to fire them. But when they are owed 1,350Tl for the month’s work, often enough, 1,280Tl waits for them in the envelope. Then they have to calculate if it is worth taking a stand for 70Tl with no protection from the law because they are working illegally. Being ground down is incremental and banal like this.

The international NGOs here in Gaziantep do not short their employees, but they do burn them out to hire fresh bodies. They hire Syrians to the lowest positions, even though Syrians have the most relevant and local knowledge, the best connections to the beneficiaries of NGOs’ programs i.e. other Syrians, the most Syrian-Arabic language (and Arabic period), and the most comprehensive knowledge of the conflict. But because of their replaceability and the entrenched position of other international staff (Syrians are technically international staff, just not with the right kind of passports), Syrians struggle to move up in NGO hierarchies. Worse, many NGOs employ staff in Syria and when their house is bombed or when they put themselves at risk, and that risk materialises, there are worst practices in place from the safe side of a difficult to cross border. Best practices are for people with recourse, people with Western passports. Syrians inside Syria were lucky to get a job with a NGO, if they lose everything in the course of their work, it is what it is. Solidarity is a word for the twitter campaign.

 

Imagine rolling hills cleared of all vegetation, that one day, from far above, had cement poured onto its highest points. And the cement flowed into each valley, coating every square foot of the land. This is how neighbourhood’s like Istanbul’s Sultanbeyli appear to have been built. A few government parks are then carved into the cement, complete with fountains and terraces of turf, and walls with gates and guards. Hosam and Walid’s living conditions did not change much between the hills north of Antalya and Istanbul’s Sultanbeyli — there were chickens in both yards. The first morning in Sultanbeyli I woke up to a kerfuffle. Two chickens, fighting, had burst through the door.

 

Hosam is protective. The language barrier is big, so when Walid isn’t around, we talk through google translate. If he thinks I am shy to eat, he pushes the lion’s share onto my plate. If he spots olive pits in my napkin, he fetches an ashtray. He is a man with middle class aspirations — a job, a wife, maybe some disposable income. To get ahead of expenses. Once we met at a mall and I offered to buy lunch anywhere he wanted — he chose KFC because he couldn’t afford it himself.

Once, in Döşemealtı, the neighbourhood of Antalya in which they used to live, I was hanging out at a big Syrian barbecue. It was twenty men in a room, preparing food, playing cards, smoking cigarettes. A fresh, charismatic face arrived, introduced himself, and sat with Walid between us (for translation).

He asked if I was a Muslim, I said no. He asked if I was a kaffir, and things quickly became uncomfortable. Not too much further into the inquiry did a third friend of ours, Muhammed, tsk at him from across the room. Muhammed had been playing cards but apparently had kept an eye on me since the new arrival. This guy is okay, don’t bother him. And that was the end of it. The stranger, who had seemed alpha a moment earlier, moved on.

WhatsApp Image 2018-06-16 at 21.10.05.jpeg

Döşemealtı developed a lot in the time between my first and last visit. In the first, there was no bus that went up the hill, and no road that went to the apartment building where the guys slept. They slept, by the way, in a room on the apartment building’s first floor, that was designed to be the building’s bodega. A big glass facade let the heat out. That development, the constant construction that powers Turkey’s economy, came at a cost. On one visit a Syrian man, who had been an Arabic teacher, had fallen from scaffolding on a nearby construction site and died. The men I ate dinner with were trying to agree on how they should protect his widow from his brother, who also lived with them at the time. Suffice to say the teacher knew nothing about navigating the hazards of work on a construction site. But an Arabic teacher from Syria in Döşemealtı would have no other opportunities for work, particularly without a work permit. My architect friend, mentioned earlier, is the exception — none of the men from Hosam and Walid’s socioeconomic strata are granted work permits, and some have been refugees in Turkey for over five years.

It was not until recently Hosam even got a kimlik, an identification he could show to Turkish police if they stopped him. Before that he was not even able to meet me at the airport, or move between cities comfortably.

Syrian men want to work, this is integral to their identity. They also want to marry, especially in this 25-35 phase that Hosam and Walid find themselves in. Their inability to even meet women — there is no time or opportunity working hard six days a week — is a source of constant psychological stress. There is an unhealthy pressure on men to find a wife and start a family in order to prove they are indeed men. The fact that sex is unavailable to them without marriage (in many cases, but not all), promotes them to rush into marriage, to assent to any potential marriage their mother and father might have set up. They rush into any opportunity because with marriage they unlock their social status, they relieve the pressure of their society, and are guaranteed to get laid. The older generation in Syria has promoted, and continues to promote, this, to the detriment of everyone. It is not uncommon for a Syrian man to get engaged over Skype. Many Syrian mothers try to arrange courtships between their refugee sons (whether they are in Turkey, Lebanon, or Jordan) and women (not at risk to join the army) who stayed in Syria. Many of these mothers are helping in this case — men like Hosam have no time for anything but working and sleeping — but the overall scheme of things is ill-equiped to deal with human realities. Many Syrian men have little skills or experience in interacting with women — learning begins after marriage. This is why men in their 50s and 60s appear wise. They, after decades of marriage, learned how to treat or not treat women, how to be good fathers and husbands. These learned skills they possess, which their unmarried sons lack, appear as proof of the process. But of course, this is confirmation bias. Many marriages end badly or would end badly, had the wife anywhere to go.

Refugees try as much as possible not to appear downtrodden, as you may have guessed from the above photos of Hosam. The risks to which one is exposed when lacking the right to work legally has nothing to do with personal hygiene or sartorial choices or stereotypical images of refugees. People do the best they can, most often.

Syrians, particularly guys like Hosam, do not want a handout. Last summer in Toronto, I had a Syrian friend call him. This friend knew a NGO which provided free medical treatment for Syrians in Turkey. At the time Hosam had a painful swelling of nymph nodes around his ear and neck — an infection treated easily enough, one imagines, by someone qualified. Hosam refused this help.

“If you can’t help bring me to Canada,” he flatly rebuffed my friend, “I don’t want your help.”

I never found out the name of the guy who died falling from the scaffolding. In Döşemealtı there was a Syrian man who had a van — he once drove me to the airport at 3am, a slight diversion from his bread route, achatter with Walid and the guys the whole way.

“He just disappeared,” Walid tells me. “I heard nothing, no one knows what happened to him.”

This has been the constant fate of Syrians in Turkey for years. No one knows what happens, but men and women, and sometimes children, slowly, routinely, banally disappear, their stories unrecorded and untold, presumably forever.

 

Canada’s missing Syrians

A new piece of mine came out on Open Canada yesterday.

In the weeks and months that followed, a framed picture of the young family from Idlib would appear facing church pews, all the way in Toronto, every Sunday.

The congregation of Beaches Presbyterian had experience with sponsorship before. They previously helped a same-sex couple settle in Canada from Iran. But after a year there was no news of an arrival date. The congregation began to worry. When were Yassin, Nour and Ahmad coming?

This took a long time. I had a lot of help — three editors, nine translators, and a photographer. The last is the brilliant Maya Hautefeuille, whose work can also be found here, here, and here. I hope you enjoy our work. Yassin 2

Please share the piece as much as you are able. I will be trying my best to promote it in the next few weeks.

Hopefully not my last writing on this important topic.

 

Reviewing Samar Yazbek

I had the fortune and opportunity to write a review of Samar Yazbek’s A Woman in the Crossfire: Diaries of the Syrian Revolution for Syria Untold.

The author takes coffee with regime-loyal couples by day and revolutionaries by night. She interviews a student protestor, then an illiterate fisherman. Each speaks at their length. The latter tells her, “We want them to leave us alone so we can live our lives, nothing more than that.” The diary fills with places and dates, the sizes of demonstrations and the methods of their suppression, the initials of the surviving and the names of the dead. She fights insomnia with Xanax.

Check out the full review here.

In Gaziantep the weather is practically balmy, the sun still beating back the chill as November gets late. But it sets early.

I am disappointed that friends here refuse group appointments because they are distrustful and grudge-bearing. I see them individually, a mixed bag of resignation and getting on with it.

A large, ongoing NGO exodus began this year, much of it unwilling. Others have set exit dates for their projects to ‘wrap up’ without conclusions. All those offices of people who never cared to learn Turkish. All those offices whose impact was better than nothing. Nearly all Syrians remain.

I see how many of the foreigners still act. They don’t get close to Syrians. When they hear someone is Syrian, their ears don’t perk up. They distance themselves with politeness. They associate with themselves. I never understood why these people came here. The most obvious explanation — that this was the best job offer on their table — that they came reluctantly — it doesn’t fully satisfy me, but I find no other explanation. The worst offenders are long gone.

And this site, with its dozens of readers. They say fail fast and often and over and over again. It will soon be thirty months since I first came to Gaziantep. And I sit here, with sporadic energy, feeling I have failed slow and once and for all.

 

But maybe there is still time.

…to Finland from Greece from Deir al-Zor

Last time I was in Athens I met the young man from this post. 

He finally got news he was being resettled in Finland a few months ago.

He says things are better there, but that he has not learned any Finnish yet.

One main complaint of his after being ‘temporarily’ in Greece for two years was that the EU resettlement plan was a lottery, so he did not know to where he would be relocated, and hence, what language he could start learning in preparation — two years of limbo, he didn’t invest in Greek and obviously not in Finnish (though his English improved). Safe to say, if he picked up a couple phrasebooks in the bookstore, or watched some youtube videos… none of them had much to do with Finnish.

I was introduced to the work of Hein de Haas at the beginning of this year by a friend here in Athens. She has a lot of experience working with refugees in Africa and the Middle East, among other places.

Over dinner some essential points were restated.

1) We are not living in an age of unprecedented migration (just look at the numbers).

2) Europe is not being invaded, particularly because refugees and migrants stay close to home. This is a silly trope that seems to be repeated by left, right, and middle everywhere, with the difference that some say compassion is the answer and some say send them back. But the premise is mistaken.

By far the majority of Syrian refugees are in Turkey, Lebanon, and Jordan — refugees take refuge overwhelmingly in neighbouring countries. And this is to some degree by choice: in Gaziantep many people have family, farms, businesses, spirit in northern Syria and they already feel sufficiently displaced. One family I know, when asked about Canada, said Canada is like the moon. “We’ve already come so far.” (They had come less than 400km). A tailor in Antep likes to remind me “we can smell the breath of Syria from here.” South Turkey is also culturally close to Syria, in Antakya (though not Gaziantep as much) people speak Arabic.

3) Development aid is no panacea to migration, the opposite is true.  This point hasn’t come up in this space that much yet, but it is important. The truly impoverished people living in squalor never get to the West. It is the middle classes of places like Nigeria, Syria, Haiti, Pakistan, and Bangladesh who end up migrating because mobility and migration require capital.

So, when the EU commits to funding development in Libya or Turkey or anywhere, in an effort to better the lives of the people whom it refuses, they are not creating a ‘stay’ factor or stymying a ‘push factor’, such that people will be more likely to stay Turkey or Libya, because it is more developed or is developing at a faster pace. Effective development widens a country’s middle class, a certain proportion of which then migrates. The more educated and better off the middle class, the more mobility they exhibit.

Why would the EU fund development then, under the auspices of reducing migration?

One answer suggested to me last night is that the EU has to justify policies of sending people back to places where those people don’t and won’t have a full slate of human rights; and human rights is of course something the EU supposedly stands for.

An accessible introduction to Hein de Haas’ work can be found here.